Within the distance comes the echo of baying hounds. They’re on the scent of a cougar. Their howls develop extra frantic because the chase picks up.
Mountain climbing behind the pack of three canines, Bart George follows the GPS trackers on their collars. They’ve trapped a feminine cougar in a tree. In hound handler converse, the canines have “treed” her.
George beforehand collared this cougar as a part of his ongoing examine as wildlife program supervisor for the Kalispel Tribe. Now, he is making an attempt to haze this 85-pound cat – by means of human voices and barking hounds – to strengthen an intuition to avoid close by neighbors and their property.
“We’re actually educating them to be cautious of people,” George says.
The cougar friends down out of the tree, at the least 50 toes within the air. She waits for the canines and folks to scatter earlier than she will be able to make her escape.
George says his analysis wouldn’t be attainable with out the assistance of his hounds – Whisper, Tipsy and Boone. He’s raised these canines and takes them out on analysis expeditions and state-requested hunts after cougars have killed or injured livestock, generally known as a depredation.
Typically these assaults occur on small pastime farms. George calls this a part of northeastern Washington a hotspot for the large cats.
George says the work has picked up. Typically he’s taking his canines out 5 days every week, typically to a number of calls a day.
“All of us have lives outdoors of this, too. Like, I’ve a younger household. (One other hound handler) runs two companies. We now have issues happening that we won’t all the time simply drop what we’re doing. However we did, and at a value financially, lacking issues at house that you do not need to be lacking,” George says. “So having extra individuals out there to drop what they’re doing and exit would assist.”
The Washington Division of Fish and Wildlife Fee not too long ago authorised a brand new rule that would quickly grant George’s want. However the rule shouldn’t be with out controversy. Many conservationists fear that coaching extra hound handlers may put a pressure on Washington’s cougar inhabitants and result in catastrophic unintended penalties for the large cats.
In 2019, lawmakers directed the fee to create the brand new non-lethal cougar pursuit coaching move rule. The rule would allow as much as 50 individuals to coach their canines annually, with as much as 4 quick relations and a non-public landowner in tow, in particular geographic areas all through the state. Hounds can be allowed to path cougars’ scent and tree the cats. New pursuit coaching guidelines are additionally speculated to be drawn up for bobcats and black bears.
A 1996 voter initiative made it unlawful to make use of hounds to hunt cougars in Washington, besides within the case of assaults on livestock, pets or for public security. The state says it wants extra skilled hound handlers and canines in order that it may capably reply to calls about these assaults.
“A part of the rationale for needing to coach on dwell (cougars) is in order that it does occur in a humane method. As a result of when a canine that’s hardwired-DNA solely will get to show unfastened to do one thing a few times a 12 months, they aren’t beneath management and they aren’t calm. It is going to grow to be inhumane to the animal that they are pursuing,” WDFW commissioner Molly Linville, a rancher in Central Washington’s Palisades, stated on the Jan. 29 fee assembly.
After prolonged oral public feedback – largely towards the rule, lots of which requested the commissioners to place off a call for additional examine – some commissioners instructed taking a number of months to tweak the language. Many different written feedback supported the rule.
“This program, in fact, is not simply going to be pursuing downside animals. Most predators and most massive carnivores by no means trigger issues. Think about if that wasn’t the case. So we’ll be pursuing cats that are not downside cats and do not actually need that lesson, per say,” stated commissioner Lorna Smith, the previous government director of Western Wildlife Outreach.
WDFW Capt. Jeff Wickersham would assist implement the brand new rule in southwestern Washington, the place many tense cougar points have popped up.
“It’s extremely apparent that there must be some very strict limits and controls on this. And I hear that loud and clear,” Wickersham stated on the assembly.
Elusive cats, troublesome examine
Now that the rule is in place, there must be issues for the way it’s applied, says Mark Elbroch, puma program director for Panthera, a wild cat conservation group. He is studied cougars – often known as pumas, panthers or mountain lions – for almost 20 years.
Elbroch, who helps the hound pursuit coaching, says there ought to be a listing of necessities to take part in this system. For instance, handlers may have a mentor. He says handlers who obtain pursuit coaching passes ought to need to contribute a service to their communities, not simply be in it for the hunt.
“These individuals exist already in Washington. If we’re going to create a program, we wish it executed effectively. I’ll be the primary to criticize it, if it’s executed poorly,” he says.
It’s laborious to know precisely what number of cougars are in Washington. The cats are elusive and troublesome to review. Loads continues to be unknown, which might complicate administration and coverage selections. After long-term analysis, WDFW estimates Washington may have as much as 2,100 cougars older than 18 months, the oldest age the cats begin to dwell independently.
Elbroch says it’s unclear whether or not extra cougar sightings imply there are extra animals or extra individuals spending time in cougar territory.
He says the cougar pattern in Washington is pretty unknown, which results in lots of hypothesis. As a substitute, he says populations ought to be managed so ecosystems are wholesome, individuals really feel protected and aren’t nervous for his or her livestock.
“I might like to see individuals shift their angst and dialogue and debate to: What do we have to keep a wholesome ecosystem and wholesome human communities? The place’s that threshold?” Elbroch says.
However that form of administration is hard. Elbroch says latest research level to the truth that heavy-handed looking can briefly scale back cougar numbers, however different cats will ultimately fill in these holes.
He says that sort of administration may result in a breakdown in younger male cat dispersal and in-breeding.
“There may be clear proof that youthful cats usually tend to have a detrimental interplay with individuals, he says. “Which means threaten individuals on climbing trails or seem of their yard to kill a canine, to kill a sheep. All of these issues usually tend to happen if it is a younger cat. And it is far more prone to happen if it is a younger cat that is hungry – and dispersers normally are.”
That’s one cause he says harvest quotas ought to be diminished.
However, this new hound coaching rule? Elbroch says it’s mandatory. He says, for now, there needs to be a center floor – between those that need all cougar looking abolished and people who want safety when their livestock or pets are killed by cougars. That center floor is hound handlers.
He says it might sound counter-intuitive, however hound handlers are sometimes “allies for (cougars) throughout the West.” They’re on the market 300-plus days a 12 months, Elbroch says, working for the state, for researchers, and on the uncommon human-safety case.
“I feel wildlife advocates do not need to hear this, nevertheless it’s true that hound hunters grow to be advocates for species. Not all of them do. In fact, there are dangerous eggs and good eggs and a few of them do not give a crap about mountain lions,” Elbroch says. “However there are a lot of who battle for that species.”
Combating for the rule
One hound handler who strongly advocated for this rule is Buddy Woodberry. He started coaching hounds after a visit to Texas greater than 20 years in the past. A buddy had discovered a stray hound, however couldn’t discover the proprietor. So Woodberry ultimately took his first hound house to Washington.
Woodberry began off looking raccoons and a few bears. Then he received into working with the general public security pilot packages for cougars with WDFW. “That type of received me tied into cats,” he says.
Now, he trains his hounds from pups. At first, simply letting them inside, getting them house-trained. Then, round six-months-old, the canine is able to head into the woods with the older hounds.
“It is investigating deer and coyotes and totally different smells that it is by no means smelled,” Woodberry stated. “It is only a technique of encouraging it on the great smells you need to comply with – no matter that’s – and discouraging it to comply with the smells you do not need to comply with: deer or coyotes or, for me, bears.”
Woodberry has helped with depredation instances and downside cougars in downtown Vancouver, Washington. However, he needed to pull his canines off cougar scents when he was coaching them within the state. Hound handlers may solely practice their canines on cougar scents outdoors of Washington.
One summer season, he was “roading” his canines – operating them alongside a wooded highway to assist them construct stamina. Then, they smelled a cougar, which they weren’t legally allowed to comply with.
He pressed a button that emits a tone on the canines’ collars. The tone calls them again their handler.
“I name them. I yell at them. I’ve to high school them slightly bit like, ‘Hey, depart that alone,’” Woodberry says.
Then, as soon as he received house, a WDFW enforcement officer referred to as. There’s a possible cougar sighting at a park in Vancouver. Might Woodberry and his canines test it out? (It turned out to be a housecat.)
“So I am taking these identical canines that I simply beeped, toned and possibly shocked for smelling a cougar. And I am telling them, ‘Oh, this time I would like you to comply with that cougar,’” Woodberry stated. “However my canines do not change their mindset inside two hours to go, ‘OK, now I need to comply with a cougar. Now I do not.’”
Whereas there are hound handlers with dangerous raps, Woodberry says this program in Washington will create well-trained canines and folks.
“I do not do that to catch cougars. I do that to work with my canines. To get nearer to my canines and to observe a pup or a younger canine begin to open up and begin to be taught,” he says. “You watch this development type of such as you watch your children.”
However some individuals fear that’s not going to be the case with all hound handlers – and the outcomes might be rather more devastating for cougars.
Worries over new rule
Debra Chase, with the Mountain Lion Basis, worries this rule permits too many hound handlers, that relations can be a part of the coaching and that handlers are allowed to hold weapons. She says this might open the door to reinstating hound attempting to find cougars in Washington.
“It is, actually, reinstating hound attempting to find only a choose variety of individuals, and that is what we’re making an attempt to cease,” Chase says. “(Hound looking is) greater than merciless. It is type of sadistic in a method, I feel. As an example that the coach goes out along with his hounds, and he chases a feminine up the tree they usually do not name the canines off straight away. She’s going to remain up that tree for fairly some time. She doesn’t get to drink or eat, and neither do her cubs.”
Chase says it was irresponsible of the WDFW commissioners to push by means of this hound coaching program. She argues that this coaching might be executed otherwise, one which’s safer for the cougars, the canines and their handlers. (Hound handlers and a few researchers say that’s not the case.)
“Hounds are utilized in different sorts of ‘sniff and monitor.’ Take hounds which might be skilled to seek out human cadavers. They’re skilled to make use of scent to discover a human cadaver, and the identical factor might be executed with wild animals,” Chase says.
She says you can saturate some material with the urine or the scent of a cougar and path it by means of the woods or tie it behind a four-wheeler. The canines may comply with that scent. She says exercising a canine doesn’t need to be with a dwell cougar.
Or, says wildlife biologist and tracker Rosemary Schiano, you can increase the state’s Karelian Bear canine program to assist with depredation incidents. Schaino, who usually provides cougar displays with the Mountain Lion Basis, says she’s nervous WDFW is “taking wildlife coverage backwards.”
“This is a gigantic concern for wildlife harassment, the harassment of already confused cougars,” Schiano says. “The opposite factor is, to be sincere, I’m extraordinarily involved that that is going to create extra battle.”
Hazing with canines needs to be executed in what Schiano calls a “correct method.” She says you could tie the hazing to a selected undesirable conduct, like going onto private property, close to livestock. Or, she says, you can professionally practice hound handlers to work as hazing groups and never tree the cougars.
She additionally believes handlers shouldn’t carry firearms.
Schiano want to see hound looking eradicated all over the place. States may change to utterly non-lethal safety strategies, which might imply individuals must be liable for their households and property. They must set up preventative gadgets, like fencing that may’t be simply jumped, and different aversion strategies, like gear with lights and sounds. She says it is all about educating householders and recreationalists.
Cougars, Schiano says, are simply being cougars. They don’t know that they shouldn’t be chomping away at pastime farms or hanging alongside climbing trails.
“So principally, you are killing the sufferer. It is like, ‘Oh, let us take a look at the symptom as an alternative of going for the trigger,’” Schiano says. “ Conflicts, I want to stress, are human created. They aren’t created by the predators, by what we name massive carnivores.”
California to Klickitat County, Washington
Each Chase and Schiano say the exemplary state to look to is California, with its progressive cougar insurance policies. The state will solely kill a cougar if it is an imminent menace to human life. In 1990, voters authorised an initiative prohibiting cougar looking, establishing the cats as a “specifically protected mammal.”
Wildlife advocates say that’s removed from the case in Washington. One prime instance of threats to the cats is in Klickitat County, the place the sheriff has gathered a posse to take care of “downside cougars.”
In 2019, the Klickitat County Sheriff’s Workplace reported a number of cougar sightings in “Goldendale, White Salmon, Glenwood, Husum, and different neighborhoods all through Klickitat County.”
“It is a critical PUBLIC SAFETY CONCERN,” Sheriff Bob Songer wrote on Fb. “Along with the Public Security Concern, cougars and bears are a significant concern and an issue for the farmers and ranchers in our County. Livestock and Home Animals are being killed by cougar (sic) and bears in our county on a daily bases (sic).”
In response, the sheriff established a program to authorize volunteer deputized hound handlers and sheriff’s deputies to be the “the Major Response to Wildlife-Human Conflicts involving Harmful Wildlife,” together with cougars and black bears. About 5 hound handlers are a part of the sheriff’s roughly 140-member posse.
A deputy and hound hunters are dispatched “to all reported harmful Wildlife conflicts that could be a (sic) danger to human security or home pets and livestock.” The hounds are licensed to trace down the “harmful animal” to be euthanized. Hound handlers are supposed to chop off the useless cougars ears so it may’t be used as a trophy kill.
“Apparently what a few of these persons are speaking about – that we’re simply operating round on the market, looking cougars down with our posse members for trophies – that could be a flat lie,” Songer stated in a telephone interview with Northwest Public Broadcasting. “In truth, in our coverage, if we had an worker or a volunteer that violates that legislation, they are going to be dealing with lots of bother. … We’re not out to shoot cats.”
In response to pushback on its Fb publish, the sheriff’s workplace replied, “We won’t be out killing each harmful animal that’s on the market. We’ll take care of those that pose a menace.”
However wildlife advocates say that’s precisely what’s occurring.
They fear Klickitat County’s public security subject is taken method too liberally. Based on a number of name logs from the sheriff’s workplace and deputy experiences, deputies and hound handlers have been dispatched after a goose was killed close to a home, as a cougar was seen exiting a sheep pasture, as one laid beneath a treehouse, after a cougar was seen sitting on a rock 60 toes from a home and after a cougar was noticed when a neighbor took a stroll.
Not all the cats have been killed. Typically the monitoring canines couldn’t discover a cougar scent.
Some complainants have been suggested to name 911-dispatch extra rapidly upon cougar sightings. The hound handlers have additionally been referred to as out to attainable bear and bobcat sightings.
Based on knowledge given to Northwest Public Broadcasting, Klickitat County hound handlers have been referred to as out at the least 63 instances over 2019 and 2020. In that point, at the least 19 cougars have been killed.
Of these cougar kills:
– At the least 9 of the cougars have been killed with little to no reported proof that they had attacked different animals, though a number of of the cats have been noticed close to livestock.
– At the least three cougars have been killed after they have been seen consuming a deer, the commonest prey for the large cats.
“When individuals see a cougar, they’re calling the sheriff’s division,” says Gabrielle Gilbert, who lives close to White Salmon in Klickitat County.
Songer says the cougar calls have dropped off considerably in latest months. “At one level, we have been getting calls left and proper,” he says.
The sheriff says it’s his job to guard livestock and pets, and particularly individuals, who he says might be injured by cougars on the town.
He pointed to an incident in 2020, the place a cougar received right into a 4-H goat pen at Columbia Excessive Faculty in White Salmon, killing 4 goats and dragging one other away. On the second day of monitoring, they killed the cat.
“Level I’m making is that in case you’ve received (a cougar) killing goats on college property, I imply, that goat may have been a child, simply as straightforward,” Songer says.
“A loss of life warrant”
Washington state’s 1996 ban on looking cougars with hounds has an exception to guard livestock, pets, non-public property or public security. Gilbert says the Klickitat County Sheriff’s Workplace is abusing these exceptions by means of a “public security loophole.”
“I imply, it’s a loss of life warrant (for cougars),” she stated.
Gilbert says Klickitat County’s emphasis on cougar kills may grow to be the pervasive angle within the state, as extra persons are skilled to trace cougars with hounds. She says it was a “laborious blow” for the WDFW fee to not desk its resolution on the coaching rule for additional examine.
“You aren’t solely in Klickitat County coping with these outcomes. You’re coping with it if it spreads to different counties within the state. And that is the cautionary story,” Gilbert says.
She desires to see coverage adjustments at WDFW so this loophole is closed and the “blatant abuses in Klickitat County aren’t allowed.”
Driving down a one-lane freeway close to Ione, Washington, biologist Bart George says he sees the brand new rule permitting extra coaching for hound-tracking as a method to assist the state’s response to security and livestock issues.
He turns his pickup onto a aspect highway, up a snowy hill. The canines behind the truck know they’re about to work. They start to howl and whine. This time, they’re in search of a cougar that’s been reported on the town. George hopes to collar it as part of his examine.
“We’d like an actual world alternative to coach our canines on dwell cougars. With out that, you simply can’t anticipate them to know what to do and how one can reply when they’re wanted on a depredation,” George says. “We wouldn’t anticipate police canines to go with out coaching. We wouldn’t anticipate drug canines to scent something aside from actual medication. They get skilled on the scent of medicine.”
George says individuals on this a part of rural Washington are nervous. They have to be educated concerning the massive cats, which he says are all over the place. Residents must learn to higher defend their livestock and pets – one thing he tries to show.
In truth, because the staff treed a cougar they’d been monitoring with GPS, 4 neighbors heard the canines baying and came visiting to see what was happening.
“You noticed the landowner present up,” George says. “He had his gun in his hand. He was nervous. It is a good alternative for them simply to see a cat in a non-threatening place. Study slightly bit about it. There are issues that he can do to button his place up slightly bit to guard his pets. There are additionally issues that, hopefully, we will do by hazing that cat, giving it some type of wholesome worry of human interplay.”
George says individuals have made it simpler for cougars to be tempted by our livestock and pets.
“We have created this example the place the deer dwell down within the valleys, and the cougars do not have a selection however to come back all the way down to the valleys, the place the persons are, to hunt,” he says. “So now we simply have to determine how one can coexist to some extent.”
Courtney Flatt covers environmental and pure sources matters for Northwest Public Broadcasting. She is predicated within the Tri-Cities. On Twitter: @courtneyflatt
Copyright 2021 Northwest Public Broadcasting. To see extra, go to nwpb.org